– 13 October 2023 –

Janus:

Does the modern state of Israel have a right to exist? Is Israel a legitimate state?

Well, the short answer to the first question is simply yes. Yes, they do.

A Nation’s Right to Exist

What gives any state or nation the right to exist or survive or assert its interests? To the extent a nation or state has rights, it has the right to exist because of its own collective will to exist, its own ability to exist in the face of internal and external threats, and God’s will to allow that state to exist. The same is true with self-assertion.

A nation has the right to its life and survival because it has earned that right, and because of God’s forbearance to allow it. Like individual liberty, a nation or state’s privileges and boundaries are earned by its collective achievements and the willingness of its communities and families to sacrifice for the collective.

National Legitimacy

As for the second question, whether Israel is a legitimate state, again the short answer is yes.

In the realm of nations, as in the realm of individuals, nations exist; and a nation possesses a degree of agency as well as the drive to survive and advance its collective interests.

Is any person’s existence illegitimate? Even a bastard child of an unwed teenaged girl is legitimate in the eyes of God and by natural law, though such a birth was the consequence of societal failure and sin. Bastard children must live with the negative consequences of their sinful birth, but that doesn’t make them illegitimate the eyes of God or in nature.

Modern Israel is much the same. A bastard child.

However shady and brutal the tactics used to establish and build the Zionist state almost from nothing, there is no question that they succeeded in doing so. Seven million Israeli Jews in all their fancy cities are a testament to that. When it comes to nations, possession and will are everything.

If a nation has the collective will to assert its interests, and its people possess the territory, then the only question is, can they defend their territory from internal and external threats? If so, then what can anyone do? Accept the reality or don’t. If a nation can and does survive, then that nation or state has every ‘right’ to do so. By that common sense logic, the modern state of Israel has as much right to exist and assert itself as any other nation or state out there.

The Israeli-Palestinian War

Of course, the same logic holds true with the Palestinian Arabs. Theirs is the weaker position, and to some extent they live at the mercy of Israel and the willingness of other countries to supply them and stand up for them. If the Palestinians choose to fight, then they have every ‘right’ to do so. And under Jewish occupation, they have every motivation to do so.

The current war is a power struggle between Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs, or at least that’s all the conflict should be. In reality, because the Jews wield so much direct and indirect power and influence in so many other countries around the world, particularly the United States, and because the Muslim world stands in some degree of solidarity with the Palestinian Arabs, then the conflict has broader implications, as we are seeing.

Should the West and other nations sacrifice their own interests for a bunch of Jews who manipulate and exploit them into ruining their own moral and ethnic cohesion to suit Jewish preferences? Of course not. But that isn’t really the Jews’ fault so much as the fault of our own stupid and corrupted peoples to tolerate this situation.

The Jews Have Earned the Wrath of the Nations

That all sounds reasonably neutral and balanced, I suppose, but here is the thing: (and the Jews know this, too, to their depths of their kvetching bones:) the collective behavior of the Jews towards pretty much everyone in the world, in both the past and the present, has given the non-Jews, and especially white Western Christians, every motivation to utterly destroy them, and not merely to destroy Israel as a state but also to destroy the Jews as an elite. So if the Jews don’t continue to impose their overwhelming influence and power over these other nations by any and every means, then those nations will turn on the Jews every bit as ruthlessly as the Palestinians have, and probably moreso.

Just as the individual liberties of people are earned and maintained to great degree by the collective assent of those around them, the same is true for nations and states.

When an individual is reasonably able to defend and take care of himself, and when he shows respect and good-will towards those around him, and if he behaves within generally tolerable norms of decency within his household, then he can expect his neighbors to leave him alone under normal circumstances. If that individual poses a danger or threat to his neighbors, or if he otherwise acts like a terrible neighbor, or if his internal abuses in his home are too egregious, then he can expect that some of his neighbors will collectively intervene to take away his some of his liberties or even remove him from his property if they can.

On the scale of nations, the Jewish diaspora (however much they might self-righteously deny it) have collectively threatened and exploited their host countries, and the Israeli Jews have done the same to other countries geopolitically.

The nefarious abuses of the diaspora Jews are conducted through their overwhelming influence and power in media, business, finance, law, government, education, and pharmaceuticals, among other means. The state of Israel abuses the world through its influence on the Jewish diaspora to manipulate the West and other lands to sacrifice their own interests for Israel’s, through Israeli intelligence agencies, through their unilateral military strikes on their neighbors, and through their Samson option nuclear policy.

This is why I don’t particularly feel sorry for the Jews in this war with the Palestinians, even while the Palestinians slaughter some Jewish civilians without direct cause (as the Israelis have done often enough, and even now, with the Palestinians.) Between Israel and the Jewish diaspora, this people has repeatedly exemplified the idea that “with friends like these, who needs enemies.”

Jews With a Homeland are Especially Dangerous

Yes, Israel has every right to defend and uphold its interests as it can and sees fit. But so does every other nation have the right to defend and uphold the interests of their own peoples against those who would destroy them.

And to defend themselves, the peoples of the world would do well to remember the example of the Jewish-Roman wars, where Jewish zealots fought like fanatical maniacs for seventy years, wiping out hundreds of thousands of non-Jewish Roman subjects, and only being crushed by ruthless Roman destruction and the forced scattering of the Jewish population.

It’s interesting that the present-day Jewish diaspora and those who grew up in Israel show increasingly divergent interests and attitudes and even appearance, however much one group still defends and upholds the other against outside threats.

For four generations now, the Israeli Jews have faced existential threats from their neighbors, they have collectively built a country almost from scratch, they have collectively worked to produce their own goods and services, and they have collectively served in the military defense of their people. This is something that is alien to the overall Jewish existence, with few exceptions, almost since their fall to Rome.

For almost two thousand years, the Jews have lived as national parasites scattered across a diaspora, kicked out of one country after another. They became increasingly weak, ugly, neurotic, paranoid, work-averse, subversive, and exploitive. These states of existence over centuries would seem to have genetically bred a people that is made to exploit their countries to the point of their persecution and expulsion. This transformation has kept the Jews cohesive and distinct from their hosts.

But now that the Jews have had a nation-state for the span of a whole lifetime, a significant number of them look healthy, uphold their own laws and norms, show civic responsibility, and have adopted right-wing nationalistic survival values. More and more of them, particularly the younger generations, are becoming like the ancient rabid zealots of Roman times after they rejected our Lord. It’s something like how domestic pigs are relatively docile and lazy when kept in their pens, but they turn into tusked wild boars when they roam free in the wild.

It seems that the world has potentially created a monster in fostering the state of Israel: a people that, for all purposes, worships itself as a religion, who are intensely fanatical in their faith and nationalistic in their attitudes, who are militaristic towards internal and external rivals, who intensely and even neurotically value education and knowledge, who consider themselves to be a true master race over all other peoples, and who already consider themselves to be in a state of existential war with everyone else.

It might well be that, even with all of the problems that diaspora Jews most certainly cause their hosts, that diaspora Jews are still preferable to the dangers posed by Jews who possess a physical homeland.

A Final Reckoning

The world may find that the only way to stop this race of ruthless fanatical nationalists is to just as ruthlessly impose their total destruction, much like the destruction that the Romans enacted. Of course, we (and they) now possess nuclear weapons, and the Jews would rather destroy the entire earth than see their homeland destroyed again.

But if the Jews can transform from domesticated pigs into wild boars, then the white race can transform from domesticated dogs into packs of wolves. Just as Roman ingenuity and determination won the day against the Jewish zealots almost two thousand years ago, innate European creativity and martial spirit can win the day against Jewish chutzpah and fanaticism.

C. F. van Niekerk:

The observations seem true enough, but the conclusions seem hysterical. How on earth can the existence of a militant Jewish state where all of the Jews live be worse than a bunch of scheming parasites sucking the life out of their zombified body-snatched host countries? Maybe that all-Jewish state would make life suck for its neighbors, but there are only so many of these people, for crying out loud.

What really makes the Jewish situation a problem is the combination of an elite and wealthy diaspora with a militant Jewish nation-state. The diaspora funnels resources from other countries and drags them into conflicts, all the while making these brain-dead hosts absorb the populations of their enemies, etc. All the while the state is emboldened to act recklessly because of that outside support and control.

Take away the diaspora, and you take away Zionist recklessness, more or less.